For most of modern astronomy, comets have been described as “dirty snowballs” — fragile lumps of ice and dust that flare to life when warmed by the Sun. But discoveries over the last few decades have persistently chipped away at that simple picture. And the newest class of mysterious bodies — dark comets — may be the most challenging puzzle yet.
They look like asteroids. They move like comets. They accelerate as if something is giving them a push — but there’s no visible coma, no glowing tail, no cloud of dust to explain the thrust.
In the past two years, researchers from NASA and Michigan State University have doubled the known tally of these objects to 14, neatly divided into two groups:
-
Outer dark comets (“outies”): large, reflective bodies on elongated orbits like Jupiter-family comets, probably from the outer solar system.
-
Inner dark comets (“innies”): small, fast-rotating bodies on near-circular orbits in the inner solar system, less than 50 meters wide.
The official explanation? Probably a trickle of invisible gas escaping from hidden ice pockets.
But what if there’s another story?
From Snowballs to Sparks: The Electric Universe View
Wal Thornhill and other proponents of the Electric Universe (EU) model have argued for decades that comets are not fragile ice relics from the solar system’s birth. Instead, they are rocky, electrically charged bodies — fragments of planetary surfaces ripped away in a recent era of cosmic catastrophe — that flare when they enter a different electrical environment.
In the EU model:
-
The coma and tail of a comet are electrical discharge phenomena, not evaporating ice clouds.
-
Comet jets can erupt from the night side, from shadowed cliffs, or from smooth plains — anywhere the local electrical stress reaches a discharge threshold.
-
Many cometary “mysteries” — jets with no vents, X-ray emissions, outbursts far from the Sun, fragments accelerating away at impossible speeds — are simply what you’d expect from a charged object encountering a changing plasma field.
The standard model demands invisible vents, buried pressure chambers, or improbable ice survival in hot sunlight. The electric model just says: the spark gap fired.
Dark Comets in an Electric Universe
Dark comets are a fresh enigma for mainstream science because they show the effects of cometary activity — measurable non-gravitational acceleration — without any of the visual signs.
For the EU thinker, that absence is not a deal-breaker. It may be the most interesting clue of all.
1. Invisible Discharges
Not every electrical exchange produces a Hollywood-style lightning bolt. In a plasma environment, micro-discharges, ion sputtering, and low-level current flows can accelerate an object without throwing off bright dust or gas clouds. If the surface is already arc-welded into glassy rock, there may be few open pathways for large-scale jets to form. The thrust is still there — just happening below the threshold of optical drama.
2. Different Plasma Regimes
The two dark comet populations suggest two different electrical environments:
-
Outies spend most of their time in the outer heliosphere, accumulating significant charge differentials before swooping inward. Their accelerations may be short-lived bursts when they cross into denser plasma regions.
-
Innies live in the inner heliosphere’s constant glow. They may experience continuous but mild charge exchange — too weak to create a coma, but steady enough to nudge their orbits in ways astronomers can detect.
3. Survivors of an Electrical Past
If comets are indeed planetary debris from ancient electrical cataclysms, many would have started their lives highly active. Over time, repeated surface arcing could leave a vitrified shell — insulating crusts that suppress visible discharge. Dark comets could be the “retired” phase of bright comets: still responsive to the Sun’s electrical field, but sparking quietly.
A ‘Oumuamua Connection?
When the interstellar visitor ‘Oumuamua whizzed past in 2017, it accelerated without a tail. Mainstream science reached for hidden ice again. Avi Loeb famously suggested a more radical alternative: maybe it was artificial, a light sail pushed by sunlight.
Dark comets may be our local cousins to ‘Oumuamua — bodies with comet-like accelerations but no visible outgassing. In an EU context, they’re simply objects whose electrical interactions are subtle, brief, or hidden from our optical instruments.
What to Look For
If EU principles apply, dark comets should still betray their electrical nature — if we look with the right tools:
-
Ultraviolet and X-ray Signatures — Even without a visible coma, charged particle exchange could produce high-energy emissions detectable by space telescopes.
-
Solar Wind Correlations — Acceleration episodes might coincide with changes in the solar wind, heliospheric current sheet crossings, or coronal mass ejections.
-
Surface Scarring — Close-up imaging could reveal scalloped crater walls, arc-melted pits, or glassy patches — all hallmarks of electric discharge machining.
-
Unexpected Molecules — OH radicals, CN, or other ions in their vicinity without matching dust output, hinting at ion sputtering from rock rather than sublimation of ice.
Why This Matters
If dark comets are electrically active bodies — even faintly — they challenge not just comet theory, but our assumptions about solar system dynamics, planetary defense, and even the sources of Earth’s water. They also add one more nail to the coffin of the “dirty snowball” model, already riddled with contradictions by missions like Deep Impact, Stardust, and Rosetta.
And in true Loeb-and-Thornhill spirit, they remind us that new categories of objects aren’t just new names — they’re opportunities to rethink the physics entirely.
The safe answer is to call them icy asteroids.
The dangerous — and perhaps more fruitful — answer is to ask: What if they’re quietly electric?
Final Thought:
We may never catch a dark comet in the act with our naked eyes. But if the Electric Universe is right, every one of them is part of the same story: relics of a charged, violent solar system past, still carrying the faint heartbeat of the sparks that made them.
Discover more from Red Sky Story
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
